FOR CRAM SCHOOLS AND TUTORS

Threads for cram schools and tutors in Taiwan: what crosses the line, and how to check posts before they go out

Cram schools in Taiwan that recruit on Threads should check these first: give the real names of the owner or teachers a post mentions, with nothing false (Art. 9(3) of the Supplementary and Continuing Education Act); sign with the full registered name, show the approving authority and registration number prominently, and avoid exaggerated or misleading claims (Arts. 6 and 17 of the short-term cram school regulations); and recruiting under a cram school name without registration brings stop orders and fines (Art. 24 of the Act). Refund wording should match Art. 24 of the regulations, ads must not use 終身 (lifelong) or 永久 (permanent) under the prohibited contract terms, and posting results lists, students' names or grades should be checked against the Fair Trade Commission's cram school Q&A (a results list must be true and detailed, and written consent from the student or their legal representative before publishing is advisable) and Art. 20 of the Personal Data Protection Act. As of 19 November 2026, MindThread has a cram school and tutoring industry pack (optional; turn it on in account settings, on paid plans and during the 14-day trial). With it on, AI-written posts, your own or imported drafts, scheduled and publish-now posts, cloud patrol comments and auto-replies are matched against the same wording rules before sending: ad wording such as 終身免費 or 永久會員 goes back to drafts; admission guarantees such as 保證錄取 and 保證考上, guaranteed improvement, "sure to pass" wording, results lists, pass rates, teacher titles, guarantee classes and no-refund wording are published with a warning; and any match stops a comment from being sent. When the account type is a registered cram school, a recruitment post needs the full registered name, the approving authority and the approval number: fill in the three fields on the settings card and leave auto-append on, and a line is added at the end when the post is published; a recruitment post without them goes back to drafts. It matches wording: it cannot check whether you hold written consent from students or parents, what the contract says or whether a teacher's name is real, and it is not legal advice. Three things you can do today: first, turn on the Industry pack in the persona section of account settings, choose cram schools and tutors, and fill in the registration details. Second, turn on approve-before-send (optional, off by default): every AI-written post goes to drafts and is published only after you review it and queue it. Third, schedule finished posts into time slots and MindThread publishes them at those times through Meta's official Threads API, so you do not have to post by hand every day. AI drafting also runs a no-fabrication check on every account (no invented student cases, unsourced figures or contact details that are not in the persona). Cloud patrol and auto-replies are also opt-in.

By the MindThread team |

Data date: 13 November 2026. Versions: Supplementary and Continuing Education Act (補習及進修教育法, amended 14 June 2017 per the national law database); Regulations Governing the Establishment and Management of Short-term Cram Schools (短期補習班設立及管理準則, amended 5 January 2021); mandatory and prohibited terms for cram school service contracts (amended 16 March 2020); cram school personal data security rules (amended 22 January 2022); Protection of Children and Youths Welfare and Rights Act (amended 20 January 2021); Personal Data Protection Act (個人資料保護法, amended 11 November 2025, with some provisions awaiting an effective date set by the Executive Yuan; Art. 20 cited here is the current text); Fair Trade Act (公平交易法, amended 14 June 2017). Original wording fetched from official pages and files on 5, 8 and 13 November 2026; the Fair Trade Commission's cram school Q&A, Art. 7 of the Personal Data Protection Act and Art. 12 of the Civil Code were fetched on 19 November 2026; MindThread's cram school pack went live on 19 November 2026, how it handles each wording reflects the code run on that day, and the provisions, contract terms and Fair Trade Commission answers the pack cites were fetched and checked again the same day. Each city and county sets its own cram school rules under the regulations, which may be stricter than this page; check your local education department. English names of laws and all English text on this page are our own translations and summaries; the Chinese original is authoritative.

Start free · MindThread plans and pricing · 中文

One week with MindThread: what your account could look like (demo)

This is a demo Threads profile we made for this page in 2026: the account, posts and engagement numbers are illustrative, not a real account or customer. The posts follow the lines described on this page, and each one passed this page's industry pack with no blocks or warnings on 19 November 2026. Taiwan accounts post in Chinese, so each post has a one-line English summary.

Demo account: tutoring

mt_demo_tutoringthreads.comIllustrative

MindThread demo account. The account, posts and numbers are illustrative.

690 followers (illustrative)

  • mt_demo_tutoring2h ago

    會考前一個月,複習可以分三步: 先做近三年的考題,再回課本補錯的單元,最後一週只做錯題。

    #Exam revision

    A month before the exam: past papers, revisit weak units, then only redo mistakes.

    Illustrative numbers: 158 likes, 17 replies, 16 reposts

  • mt_demo_tutoring1d ago

    作業寫很久,可以試著切成 20 分鐘一段,中間休息 5 分鐘。 每個孩子節奏不同,先觀察一週再調整。

    #Study habits

    Split homework into 20-minute blocks with 5-minute breaks, then adjust after a week.

    Illustrative numbers: 121 likes, 13 replies, 9 reposts

  • mt_demo_tutoring2d ago

    英文單字別只背中文意思,連同一個例句一起記。 用得出來,才算記住。

    #Learning English

    Learn each English word with an example sentence, not just its meaning.

    Illustrative numbers: 134 likes, 10 replies, 11 reposts

  • mt_demo_tutoring3d ago

    數學錯題本只要三欄:題目、錯在哪、正確的想法。 抄答案不如寫下自己卡在哪一步。

    #Maths

    A maths mistake log needs three columns: the question, the error and the right approach.

    Illustrative numbers: 147 likes, 12 replies, 14 reposts

  • mt_demo_tutoring5d ago

    家長常問:「要不要提早學下學期的進度?」 先看這學期的觀念穩不穩,再決定。

    #Parent questions

    Should children study ahead? First check that this term’s concepts are solid.

    Illustrative numbers: 92 likes, 15 replies, 4 reposts

  • mt_demo_tutoring6d ago

    這週的課堂小練習:用三句話說明一個自然現象。 說得出來,代表真的懂了。

    #In class

    This week’s class exercise: explain a natural phenomenon in three sentences.

    Illustrative numbers: 78 likes, 6 replies, 3 reposts

Demo only: the account, posts and numbers are illustrative.

Start free

Which rules apply when Taiwan cram schools and tutors post on Threads?

As of November 2026, cram schools recruiting on Threads should check Arts. 9 and 24 of the Supplementary and Continuing Education Act, Arts. 2, 6, 16, 17 and 24 of the short-term cram school regulations, and the mandatory and prohibited contract terms; results lists and posts about students should also be checked against the Fair Trade Commission's cram school Q&A, Arts. 7 and 20 of the Personal Data Protection Act and Art. 69 of the Child and Youth Welfare Act, and truth in advertising against Art. 21 of the Fair Trade Act. The Threads wording after each rule is our own example, not wording from the rules.

  1. Supplementary and Continuing Education Act (補習及進修教育法) Art. 9(3) and 9(13)

    Our summary: when a cram school's enrolment, contracts, or ads and publicity through its premises, media or other means mention the owner or staff, their real names must be disclosed and nothing may be false; the same applies when the owner or staff recruit or advertise. Breaches can bring a fine of NT$50,000 to NT$250,000 on the person in charge, an order to improve, repeated fines, and if necessary a halt to enrolment or revocation of registration. The article does not name social media; treating a Threads post as advertising or publicity "through media or other means" is our reading, and so is "a stage name is fine as long as the real name is also given".

    Original Chinese text (authoritative):

    短期補習班之招生、書面契約及利用其場址、傳播媒體或其他方法所為之廣告或宣傳,涉及負責人、教職員工姓名時,除立案名稱外,均應揭露其真實姓名,且不得有虛偽不實之情形;其負責人、教職員工執行業務及對外招生或廣告時,亦同。…短期補習班違反第三項至第五項、第九項或第十項規定者,直轄市、縣(市)主管教育行政機關應處其負責人新臺幣五萬元以上二十五萬元以下罰鍰,並得令其限期改善,屆期未改善者,按次處罰;必要時並令其停止招生或廢止短期補習班立案。
  2. Supplementary and Continuing Education Act Art. 24(1)

    Our summary: anyone who recruits students under the name of a cram school, or a name like one, without approved registration is ordered to stop at once and publicly named; equipment may be confiscated, the person in charge is fined NT$50,000 to NT$250,000, and daily fines can follow if they keep going. On Threads this covers "early-bird enrolment" posted before registration is approved, and unregistered tutors or studios calling themselves a cram school. Whether names like 學苑 or 教室 count as "like a cram school" is not defined in the article and is for the authority to decide.

    Original Chinese text (authoritative):

    未依法申請核准立案,而以補習班或類似補習班名義擅自招生者,由直轄市、縣(市)主管教育行政機關命其立即停辦,並公告之;其所使用之器材、設備得沒入;其負責人處新臺幣五萬元以上二十五萬元以下罰鍰;經處罰鍰後仍不遵令停辦者,得按日連續處罰。
  3. Regulations Governing the Establishment and Management of Short-term Cram Schools (短期補習班設立及管理準則) Art. 2

    Our summary: a cram school under these regulations has a fixed site, recruits five or more students and charges fees; courses registered or approved under other laws are excluded. One-to-one home tutoring or purely online courses with no fixed site often fall outside this definition, so the brochure, registration number and refund rules may not apply directly. That is our reading; the authority decides case by case, and it does not mean tutors are unregulated. Anyone who charges for teaching still has to advertise truthfully (see Fair Trade Act Art. 21 below; whether an individual tutor counts as an "enterprise" under that article is our reading).

    Original Chinese text (authoritative):

    本準則所稱短期補習班(以下簡稱補習班),指於固定場址,對外招生達五人以上,並收取費用,辦理本法第三條所定短期補習教育之機構。私人或團體依其他法令規定,向中央或直轄市、縣(市)政府所屬相關機關辦理登記或申請核准舉辦之訓練、活動或課程,不適用本準則之規定。
  4. Short-term Cram School Regulations Art. 6(4)

    Our summary: when a cram school recruits students or enters legal acts, it must sign with the full registered name. On Threads that means a recruitment post should show the full registered name, not only a brand nickname or a teacher's name. The rule does not say whether the account name itself must match; putting the full name in the post text or a pinned post is our cautious reading.

    Original Chinese text (authoritative):

    補習班對外招生或為其他法律行為時,應以核准立案之名稱全名具名。
  5. Short-term Cram School Regulations Art. 17(2) and 17(3)

    Our summary: recruitment must be honest, open and accurate; publicity and ads must not exaggerate, mislead, offend public order or break other laws, and must show the approving authority and registration number in a prominent place. On Threads this covers unsupported claims such as "guaranteed admission" or "90% of students improve by 20 points", and posts without the registration number. The rule does not say whether "prominent place" means the post text or the image; putting it in both is our cautious reading. Article 35 item 6 lists exaggerated recruitment ads among the cases where the authority may correct, order improvement or halt enrolment.

    Original Chinese text (authoritative):

    補習班招生應秉持誠信、公開、正確之原則,其宣傳資料或廣告內容,不得誇大不實、引人誤解、違反公序良俗或其他相關法令之規定。前項宣傳或廣告,應於明顯處載明核准立案之機關及文號。
  6. Short-term Cram School Regulations Art. 16

    Our summary: an enrolment brochure must include the approved subjects, number of classes and students, start date, course length, fee and refund rules, the approving authority and registration number, and anything else the local authority requires. Whether a Threads recruitment post counts as a brochure is not stated; a cautious approach is to point readers to the full brochure whenever a post uses brochure details such as dates or fees.

    Original Chinese text (authoritative):

    補習班招生簡章內容,應包括核准辦理之類科、招收班數、人數、開課日期、當期修業期間、收退費規定、核准立案之機關與文號,及其他直轄市、縣(市)主管教育行政機關規定之事項。
  7. Short-term Cram School Regulations Art. 24(1), 24(3) and 24(8)

    Our summary: refunds when a student leaves after paying: 90% before the actual start date (anything over NT$1,000 within the 10% kept must still be refunded); half if the request comes before one third of the term or course hours; nothing need be refunded after one third. Registration fees, deposits and other charges may not be deducted from the total, and local rules that favour consumers prevail. On Threads this covers lines like "no refunds once paid" or "registration fee non-refundable". Treating "no refunds" as misleading publicity is our reading of this article together with Article 17.

    Original Chinese text (authoritative):

    補習班學生繳納費用後離班者,補習班應依下列規定辦理退費:一、學生於實際開課日前提出退費申請者,應退還當期開班約定繳納費用總額百分之九十。但所收取之百分之十部分逾新臺幣一千元部分,仍應退還。二、學生於實際開課日起,且未達全期或總課程時數之三分之一期間內提出退費申請者,應退還當期開班約定繳納費用總額之二分之一。三、學生於達全期或總課程時數之三分之一以上期間提出退費申請者,所收取之當期開班約定繳納費用得全數不予退還。…第一項約定繳納費用總額,不得扣除補習班訂定之報名費、訂位金或其他收費項目。…第一項退費,直轄市、縣(市)主管教育行政機關為提升對消費者權益之保護或其他公益性因素,於自治法規訂定更有利於消費者之規定者,從其規定。
  8. Mandatory and prohibited terms for short-term cram school service contracts (短期補習班補習服務契約書應記載及不得記載事項) Part II, item 3

    Our summary: the cram school's advertising must not use 終身 (lifelong), 永久 (permanent) or similar wording. On Threads this covers "free lifelong re-takes" or "permanent review access". Whether 一輩子 or 無限期 count as similar is for the authority to decide; avoiding them is the cautious choice. The source is the list of prohibited contract terms, and this page does not present it as a separate penalty.

    Original Chinese text (authoritative):

    三、乙方之廣告說明,不得使用「終身」、「永久」等用語或類此字樣。
  9. Mandatory and prohibited terms for short-term cram school service contracts Part I, item 17

    Our summary: the contract's attachments and related ads are part of the contract. Course content, free sessions and teachers named in a recruitment post may be treated as contract terms; treating a Threads post as a "related ad" is our reading. Consumer Protection Act Art. 22 likewise says a business's obligations to consumers may not fall below its ad. Item 6 of the same terms requires guarantee classes to state the guarantee and its period in the contract, so any guarantee in a post should match the contract (our reading).

    Original Chinese text (authoritative):

    本契約之附件及相關廣告視為本契約之一部分。
  10. Fair Trade Commission Q&A on cram schools (公平交易委員會常見問答) On why written consent before publishing a results list is "advisable" (page updated 25 December 2013)

    Our summary: this is the regulator's direct answer on results lists. A published list must be true and detailed; getting written consent from the student or their legal representative before publishing is "advisable" (宜), which the answer says is not a mandatory rule; and a cram school that publishes without written consent bears the burden of proof if a dispute follows. Article 24 of the Fair Trade Act cited in the answer is the 2013 numbering; the current provision on obviously unfair conduct is Article 25 (our reading from comparing the text). Another answer in the same set adds that consent may not be collected through a standard contract clause signed at enrolment. The Q&A does not mention social platforms; applying it to results lists on Threads is our reading.

    Original Chinese text (authoritative):

    補習班所刊登榜單之內容必須真實、詳盡,而本規範說明規定「升學文理補習班以錄取榜單暨成績資料引為促銷資訊時,宜於刊登前取得學生或其法定代理人書面同意」,其「宜」字並非強制規定,出發點係為衡平補習班及消費者權益,避免有不當促銷行為。且補習班以錄取榜單暨成績資料引為促銷資訊,而於刊登榜單前,取得學生或其法定代理人書面同意,將可消弭交易糾紛於無形,若未於刊登榜單前取得學生或其法定代理人書面同意,則補習班仍須自負舉證風險,並須避免因刊登榜單衍生爭議,而有觸犯公平交易法第21條及第24條規定之虞之情形。
  11. Fair Trade Commission Q&A on cram schools On whether a clause in the parent handbook counts as consent (page updated 25 December 2013)

    Our summary: a clause pre-printed in the parent handbook or enrolment form should not stand in for consent; the cram school should prepare a separate written form for the student or legal representative to review and sign. The answer says "under 20" because that was the age of majority in 2013; Article 12 of the Civil Code now reads 滿十八歲為成年 (adulthood begins at 18), so today it is students under 18 who need a legal representative's consent as well (the age conversion is our reading of the current Civil Code). On the commission's page the last sentence of this answer is cut off after 審閱及簽章同; we quote only the complete part.

    Original Chinese text (authoritative):

    補習班以學生榜單做招生廣告時,若學生未滿20歲,依民法規定,必須取得家長書面同意,而且消費者保護法已規定定型化契約須給消費者一定之審閱期間,故不宜以補習報名當時所提供的家長手冊代替,補習班宜另外製作書面表單供學生或其法定代理人審閱及簽章
  12. Personal Data Protection Act Art. 7(2) and 7(4)

    Our summary: consent to use personal data beyond the original purpose means a separate declaration made after the collector has clearly explained the other purpose, its scope and how agreeing or refusing affects the person; the collector bears the burden of proving that consent was given. So keep the consent form separate from the enrolment form, let people tick name, school, grades and photo one by one (itemised boxes are our suggestion; the Act only says a separate declaration), and keep the signed copy.

    Original Chinese text (authoritative):

    第十六條第七款、第二十條第一項第六款所稱同意,指當事人經蒐集者明確告知特定目的外之其他利用目的、範圍及同意與否對其權益之影響後,單獨所為之意思表示。…蒐集者就本法所稱經當事人同意之事實,應負舉證責任。
  13. Personal Data Protection Act (個人資料保護法) Art. 20(1) and 20(2)

    Our summary: a non-government body must use personal data within the purpose for which it was collected, with exceptions such as the person's consent or the person's benefit; when data is used for marketing and the person refuses, the marketing must stop. Students' names, schools and grades are collected for teaching, so using them in recruitment posts is safer with prior consent (our reading). Article 19 of the same Act covers collection and processing. Some amendments of 11 November 2025 await an effective date set by the Executive Yuan, so this page does not state fine amounts under this Act.

    Original Chinese text (authoritative):

    非公務機關對個人資料之利用,除第六條第一項所規定資料外,應於蒐集之特定目的必要範圍內為之。但有下列情形之一者,得為特定目的外之利用:…六、經當事人同意。七、有利於當事人權益。非公務機關依前項規定利用個人資料行銷者,當事人表示拒絕接受行銷時,應即停止利用其個人資料行銷。
  14. Implementation Rules for Personal Data Security Plans of Short-term Cram Schools (短期補習班個人資料檔案安全維護計畫實施辦法) Art. 11

    Our summary: when a cram school uses personal data for publicity, promotion or marketing under Art. 20(1) of 本法 ("this Act"; that it means the Personal Data Protection Act is our reading), it must tell the person its registered name and where the data came from; the first time, it must offer a way to refuse at its own cost, and once the person refuses it must stop at once and tell its staff. On Threads this matters for DMs and other one-to-one recruitment messages; that a public post is not marketing to a specific person is our reading.

    Original Chinese text (authoritative):

    補習班依本法第二十條第一項規定利用個人資料為宣傳、推廣或行銷時,應明確告知當事人補習班立案名稱及個人資料來源。補習班於首次利用個人資料為宣傳、推廣或行銷時,應提供當事人表示拒絕接受宣傳、推廣或行銷之方式,並支付所需費用;當事人表示拒絕接受宣傳、推廣或行銷者,應立即停止利用其個人資料宣傳、推廣或行銷,並周知所屬人員。
  15. Protection of Children and Youths Welfare and Rights Act (兒童及少年福利與權益保障法) Art. 69(1) and 69(3)

    Our summary: media, including the internet, must not report the names or other identifying details of four groups of children: those subjected to acts listed in Arts. 49 or 56(1), those using drugs or harmful substances, parties to custody, adoption or similar family cases, and parties or victims in criminal or juvenile protection cases; nobody else may publicly disclose them either. Ordinary students' photos and grades are not in these groups, so this is not a rule against posting student photos. The risk is "inspiring story" posts that reveal, for example, a custody case together with a name, school or photo. Breaching paragraph 1 can bring a fine of NT$30,000 to NT$150,000 on the person in charge under Art. 103(2), with removal orders; where there is no person in charge, or the person in charge has no supervisory relationship with the person who posted, Art. 103(4) fines the person who posted; breaching paragraph 3 without good reason can bring NT$20,000 to NT$100,000 under Art. 89. Which paragraph covers a teacher's personal account is for the authority to decide.

    Original Chinese text (authoritative):

    宣傳品、出版品、廣播、電視、網際網路或其他媒體對下列兒童及少年不得報導或記載其姓名或其他足以識別身分之資訊:一、遭受第四十九條或第五十六條第一項各款行為。二、施用毒品、非法施用管制藥品或其他有害身心健康之物質。三、為否認子女之訴、收養事件、親權行使、負擔事件或監護權之選定、酌定、改定事件之當事人或關係人。四、為刑事案件、少年保護事件之當事人或被害人。…除前二項以外之任何人亦不得於媒體、資訊或以其他公示方式揭示有關第一項兒童及少年之姓名及其他足以識別身分之資訊。
  16. Fair Trade Act (公平交易法) Art. 21(1) and 21(4)

    Our summary: businesses must not make false or misleading representations about matters that affect buying decisions, and this applies to services. The Fair Trade Commission has handled two education-related ad cases: in 2009 a cram school claimed its top-score students outnumbered at least 50% of all such students in Taipei, far exceeded all other cram schools combined, and that its top-band ratio was 8 to 10 times its peers'; this was found false and misleading about service quality, the comparison was also found unfair, and it was fined NT$500,000. In 2010 a review-book publisher printed "number one in sales" on covers and bands, which was found false and misleading about product quality. Both used the article numbers of the Act at the time; that they correspond to today's Arts. 21 and 25 is our reading based on comparing the text.

    Original Chinese text (authoritative):

    事業不得在商品或廣告上,或以其他使公眾得知之方法,對於與商品相關而足以影響交易決定之事項,為虛偽不實或引人錯誤之表示或表徵。…前三項規定,於事業之服務準用之。

A student quits a cram school course partway: how much tuition must be refunded?

Under Article 24 of the short-term cram school regulations (amended 5 January 2021 and still in force in November 2026), a refund requested before the actual start date is 90% of the total fees for the term, and any part of the 10% kept that exceeds NT$1,000 must still be refunded; before one third of the term or course has passed, half is refunded; from one third on, the school may keep all fees. Registration and seat-booking fees may not be deducted from the total, fees collected on the student's behalf are refunded in full, and more favourable local rules prevail.

How the cram school refund calculator works (each step with its source and the original wording)

Codes such as R-B1 are this page's labels for the refund rules, so you can match them to the estimate below; rows marked "our method" are calculation details the rule text does not spell out (for example how to round), and the rest follow the rule text.

RuleSource and original wording
R-B1 Before the start date: the school may keep at most 10% of the total, capped at NT$1,000; the rest is refunded. Fractions of a dollar go to the student (rounded down). (our method)S204
學生於實際開課日前提出退費申請者,應退還當期開班約定繳納費用總額百分之九十。但所收取之百分之十部分逾新臺幣一千元部分,仍應退還。
R-B2 Deposit only, leaving before the start date: the school keeps no more than the deposit and may not ask you to top it up.S204
學生僅繳納訂金,於開課前即離班者,補習班不得要求其補足補習班依第一項第一款規定得扣除之學費不足額部分。
R-B3 After the start, before one third of the term or course: half of the total is refunded (rounded up to the dollar). (our method)S204
學生於實際開課日起,且未達全期或總課程時數之三分之一期間內提出退費申請者,應退還當期開班約定繳納費用總額之二分之一。
R-B4 One third or more (exactly one third counts): the school may keep all of it; the rule says "may", so a school can still choose to refund.S204
學生於達全期或總課程時數之三分之一以上期間提出退費申請者,所收取之當期開班約定繳納費用得全數不予退還。
R-B5 Registration fees, seat-booking fees and other charges may not be deducted from the total.S204
第一項約定繳納費用總額,不得扣除補習班訂定之報名費、訂位金或其他收費項目。
R-B6 Fees collected on your behalf are refunded in full; if items were already bought, you get the items.S204
補習班所收取之代辦費,應全額退還。但已購置成品者,發給成品。
R-B7 Local rules that are more favourable to students prevail; this calculates the national floor.S204, S209
第一項退費,直轄市、縣(市)主管教育行政機關為提升對消費者權益之保護或其他公益性因素,於自治法規訂定更有利於消費者之規定者,從其規定。
R-B8 The agreed refund must be completed within one month of the cancellation.S209
甲乙雙方所約定之退費方式應於辦理解約手續後一個月內執行完竣。
R-B9 For a minor, the school must notify the legal guardian to collect the refund.S203
補習班處理退費事宜時,亦同,該退費並應通知其法定代理人具領。
R-B10 This only applies to registered short-term cram schools; tutors and one-person studios depend on whether they fit the definition.S198
本準則所稱短期補習班(以下簡稱補習班),指於固定場址,對外招生達五人以上,並收取費用,辦理本法第三條所定短期補習教育之機構。

Refund calculator: enter the amounts and dates and it applies the rules above (needs JavaScript; without it, the table above is its full method).

This is an estimate calculated from the rule text, not legal advice; the actual refund depends on your contract and the authority's interpretation. This is the minimum the national rules require; a school may refund more. Data date 2026-11-13 | Rule versions: Short-term cram school regulations (amended 5 January 2021); mandatory and prohibited terms for cram school service contracts (amended 16 March 2020). If you find a mistake, tell us through the contact page; we will fix it and add the correction date here.

Rules this tool uses (Chinese originals):

The cram school says the registration fee is non-refundable. Is that allowed?

Article 24(3) says registration fees, seat-booking fees and other charges may not be deducted from the total used to calculate the refund, so the registration fee is refunded in the same proportion. More favourable local rules prevail.

How do I know whether one third of the course has passed?

Use what the contract counts: sessions, hours or a period. If the contract says nothing, use the classes actually held (Art. 24(6)). If you joined mid-course, count from the first class after you enrolled and treat the rest of the course as the whole.

Start free

Does MindThread's industry pack catch this wording?

It blocks the wording that official texts list, and flags or skips the rest. As of 19 November 2026, for a MindThread account with the cram school pack on, AI-written posts, your own or imported drafts, scheduled and publish-now posts, cloud patrol comments and auto-replies are all checked by the same rules before sending (except cloud patrol comments you edit by hand in the pending list): 終身 or 永久 in ad wording and a registered cram school's recruitment post without its registration details go back to drafts with the basis; admission guarantees (Article 17(2) of the regulations is a general bar on exaggerated or misleading ads and does not list the phrases, so they only get a warning), guaranteed improvement, "sure to pass" wording, results lists, rates, teacher titles, guarantee classes and no-refund wording are published with a warning; and any match stops a comment from being sent. The last column of the table says what the pack does first, then gives a suggested rewrite; rows marked "not checked" are yours to review.

The pack's rules match Traditional Chinese wording; the table gives the Chinese phrases with our translations. English is matched only for a few phrases, such as "guaranteed admission" and "100% pass" (both get a warning). The pack matches wording and is not legal advice: it cannot check whether a teacher's name is real, whether a student or parent gave written consent, whether the contract states what is guaranteed, or whether the school is registered. An admission guarantee gets a warning in a post and is not blocked; when the same sentence mentions a guarantee class (保證班), what is guaranteed or the guarantee period, the warning is about putting the guarantee and its period in the contract (the contract terms require both). Any match stops a comment from being sent. Tutor accounts have no required fields, and recruiting as a 補習班 gets a warning; 終身 and 永久 are blocked only for registered cram schools (the contract terms govern cram schools), and tutors get a warning. Local cram school rules set by each city and county are not in the pack.

Does MindThread's industry pack catch this wording?
WordingRule to checkWhat the pack does, and a suggested rewrite
Recruitment posts that give only a teacher's stage name or nickname (數學魔王), not the real nameSupplementary and Continuing Education Act Art. 9(3)Pack: not checked (it cannot tell a stage name from a real name). Give the teacher's real name; a stage name can be added (our reading)
Listing people who do not teach at the school as its teachers, or advertising "taught by star teachers" and then using substitutesAct Art. 9(3) (nothing false); contract terms Part I item 7 (limits on replacing teachers)Pack: 名師親授 gets a warning; who actually teaches cannot be checked. Name only the teachers who actually teach; update posts when teachers change
Opening "early-bird enrolment" while registration is pending; unregistered tutors or studios calling themselves a cram school (補習班)Act Art. 24Pack: a post saying 立案申請中 or 尚未立案 gets a warning; a tutor account recruiting as a 補習班 gets a warning; registration itself cannot be checked. Recruit only after approval; if unregistered, describe yourself as what you are, such as a tutor or online course
Recruitment posts with only a brand nickname and no full registered name, approving authority or registration numberRegulations Arts. 6(4) and 17(3)Pack: for a registered cram school account, a recruitment post without the full registered name, the approving authority or the approval number is blocked (returned to drafts); with the three fields filled in and auto-append on, a line is added at the end when the post is published. Put the full registered name, authority and registration number in the post text or a pinned post, and on the image (the image is our cautious choice)
Guaranteed admission, strongest in Taiwan, 90% of students up 20 points (保證考上, 全台最強) with no basisRegulations Art. 17(2); Fair Trade Act Art. 21Pack: 保證考上, 全台最強 and improvement percentages all get a warning (Article 17(2) of the regulations is a general rule and does not list the phrases). State checkable facts: course content, weekly hours, teachers' background
Results posts claiming ratios, multiples or "more than all other cram schools combined"Fair Trade Act Arts. 21 and 25; the 2009 FTC case (old article numbers, see above)Pack: warning. Give only numbers you can document and say what they are based on; do not compare with other schools
Calling a review book or online course "number one in sales" (銷售第一)Fair Trade Act Art. 21; the 2010 FTC casePack: warning. Drop the ranking; describe the content and who it suits
"Limited places, no refunds once paid", "registration fee non-refundable" (恕不退費)Regulations Art. 24(1) and 24(3)Pack: 恕不退費 and 報名費不退 get a warning. Say refunds follow Art. 24 and local rules, and link the full fee and refund terms
Free lifelong re-takes, permanent review access (終身, 永久)Prohibited contract terms Part II item 3Pack: blocked (registered cram school accounts; tutors only get a warning and information accounts are not checked). State a clear period and number of times, such as one free re-take within a year of finishing
Promising admission or a full refund while the contract states no guarantee termsContract terms Part I items 6 and 17 (that the post must match the contract is our reading)Pack: 保證上榜 and the refund promise both get a warning (what the contract says cannot be checked). Put the guarantee and its period in the contract first, and keep the post consistent with it
Posting results lists, students' names, schools, grades or face photos to recruitFair Trade Commission cram school Q&A (written consent before publishing is advisable, not mandatory; a parent handbook clause should not stand in for it); Personal Data Protection Act Arts. 7, 19 and 20Pack: 榜單 or a congratulation line gets a warning; written consent cannot be checked. After results come out and before publishing, have a separate written consent form signed, not a clause in the enrolment form or parent handbook; without consent, remove names, schools and photos; keep the data behind every number on the list
Inspiring-story posts that reveal a custody case or abuse together with details that identify the studentChild and Youth Welfare Act Art. 69(1) and 69(3) (penalties Art. 103(2) and Art. 89)Pack: not checked. Leave out anything that identifies the student; share study methods only
DMs to parent or former-student lists without the registered name, the source of the list or a way to opt outCram school personal data rules Art. 11; Personal Data Protection Act Art. 20Pack: not checked (private messages do not go through MindThread). State the registered name and the source of the list, offer an opt-out in the first message, and stop if asked

What you can use in MindThread today (all in the dashboard)

  • Turn it on in account settings, persona section: the Industry pack card, choose cram schools and tutors, then registered cram school, private tutor (not registered), or study and admissions information (not a business). It is off by default and is never turned on for an account automatically.
  • Required disclosure for a registered cram school: the full registered name, the approving authority and the approval number. With auto-append on, recruitment posts get "full registered name | 立案:authority number" at the end when published; if the three fields are incomplete, a recruitment post goes back to drafts. Tutor and information accounts have no required fields.
  • The cram school pack has no "I am the licensed professional" box. When the AI writes posts, its instructions include the cram school rules (no outcome guarantees, no invented results lists or teacher backgrounds, no promises to an individual student); the draft is then checked by the same rules and rewritten once if anything matches.
  • Drafts you write or import into the content library, scheduled posts and publish-now posts are checked by the same rules before they go out; a blocked draft goes back to drafts with the account, the sentence and the basis, and one-click rewrite rewrites and re-checks it, returning only a passing draft to the queue (counts as one AI generation).
  • A warning does not stop a post and nothing pops up when you publish; matches are counted on the settings card under the rules matched most this month, and the preview before you turn a pack on shows how many queued drafts would be returned, which sentence matched, and how many would only get a warning. Read warned wording again yourself.
  • Cloud patrol comments and auto-replies are not sent if any rule matches (a comment answers one specific person, so the pack is strict there); a comment you edit in the pending list is not checked by the pack again when you approve it. Approve-before-send is optional and off by default; we suggest turning it on.
  • A false-positive report button sits next to each reason. Posts sent to Instagram or Facebook through MindThread do not go through the pack.

What can cram schools and tutors post on Threads? Three cautious examples

We ran these three posts through MindThread's cram school pack on 19 November 2026 and each came back with 0 blocks and 0 warnings: the study tip passes in all three account types, the recruitment introduction uses the registered cram school setting and the self-introduction uses the private tutor setting. They promise no results, give no student details and make no comparisons; run through the AI's no-fabrication check in its stricter mode as well, all three had 0 hits. Whether they are acceptable is ultimately for the authorities to decide.

Study tip: revising in the last month before the junior high exam

國中會考前一個月,複習可以分三步:先把近三年的會考題做一輪,標出錯的單元;再回課本把那幾個單元的觀念重讀;最後一週只做錯題,不開新題。每個孩子卡住的地方不同,錯題整理好,比多做幾本題目有用。

Our summary: work through the last three years of exam papers, mark weak units, reread those concepts, and in the final week redo only the questions you got wrong. It gives no conclusion about anyone's child and does not recruit; cram schools, teachers and tutors can all use it as a reference.

Recruitment introduction (registered cram school accounts)

〇〇文理短期補習班(立案全名),核准立案機關與文號:〇〇市政府教育局〇〇字第〇〇〇〇號。國二數學班每週二、四晚上上課,任課老師〇〇〇(真實姓名),學歷與教學經歷寫在主頁;完整簡章、收費與退費規定也在主頁。

Our summary: full registered name, approving authority and registration number, the teacher's real name, and the full brochure with fee and refund rules on the profile. These follow Art. 6(4) and 17(3) of the regulations and Art. 9(3) of the Act; no guarantees, ratios or comparisons. 〇〇 marks placeholders for your own real details.

Self-introduction (tutor accounts)

我是家教老師〇〇〇,一對一教國中英文,可以到府或線上上課。第一堂先做程度測驗,再依結果排進度;每堂的時數、費用、請假與退費方式,開始上課前用書面寫清楚。

Our summary: a home tutor giving a real name, teaching junior high English one-to-one at home or online, starting with a placement test, and setting out hours, fees, leave and refunds in writing before lessons begin. It describes the account as a tutor, not a cram school (Art. 24 of the Act); whether the regulations apply to tutors is for the authority to decide case by case.

Passing the pack means no rule in this set matched; it is not a statement that a post is legally sound. The pack is an assistive check, not legal advice, and members are responsible for their posts and comments.

Cloud patrol and auto-replies for cram school accounts: uses and limits

As of 13 November 2026, scheduled posts, cloud patrol and auto-replies in MindThread all go through Meta's official Threads API, using your account's own authorisation. Browser patrol is a separate, optional Chrome extension that runs in your own browser with the Threads account you are logged into there; it does not use the official API, is a grey area under the platform's terms, carries account risk, is offered only to members in Taiwan, and is used only if you install it yourself.

  • For a cram school or tutoring account with the pack on, cloud patrol comments and auto-replies are checked before sending and are not sent if any rule matches; keep comments free of recruitment, promised results and comparisons with other schools. Accounts without the pack are not checked. Approve-before-send is a cloud patrol option: with it on, each comment waits for your approval, and we suggest turning it on.
  • Cloud patrol searches keywords with the account's own official Meta authorisation and comments on matching public posts. It is off by default; approve-before-send is optional, and with it on every comment waits for your approval.
  • Patrol points are a daily allowance included in your plan, not an extra charge (more can be bought as an add-on). They are shared by all accounts under one login and reset every day on Taipei time: 50 a day during a new sign-up's 14-day trial, 300 on Connect, 500 on Pro and 1,500 on Business, and none on the Free plan once the trial ends. Each post found costs 1 point and each reply we post for you costs 3 points (accounts registered before November 2026 still pay 1 point per reply); find-only mode is charged only for posts found. Nothing posted, nothing charged; when the points run out, patrol stops for the day and resumes the next day.
  • Comments should explain what to look at and how to prepare, without "DM us to enrol" or "guaranteed admission" lines, comparisons with other schools or conclusions about someone's child. We read a cram school recruiting under someone else's post as recruitment publicity under Art. 17(2) of the regulations (our reading).
  • Auto-replies to comments under your own posts use the persona when no separate reply style is set; saved fixed replies get no industry check either.
  • Browser patrol (Chrome extension) comments go through an industry pack only when three things are all true: the Threads account signed in to the extension is linked to MindThread, that account has a pack on, and the extension version reports the account name; otherwise they are sent as before. Posts the extension publishes on its own do not go through the pack.
  • We never claim patrol carries no ban risk. A reply posted for you can be treated by Threads as repetitive, or be reported by the other person; that is why cloud patrol is off by default, each account has a daily reply cap (10 by default, adjustable), a new reply that is too similar to recent ones is rewritten or skipped, and we suggest turning on approve-before-send. These lower the risk; they do not remove it.

How patrol works and its risks (Chinese) In English, the three points on that page: scheduled posts, cloud patrol and auto-replies use Meta's official Threads API; browser patrol is a Chrome extension that does not use the official API, is a grey area under the platform's terms and carries account risk; and browser patrol is offered only to members in Taiwan.

FAQ

May cram schools in Taiwan run a Threads account and post recruitment content?
The rules do not name Threads or social media. Art. 9(3) of the Supplementary and Continuing Education Act covers a short-term cram school's ads and publicity "through its premises, media or other means"; Art. 17(2) of the cram school regulations bars exaggerated or misleading publicity and ads, and Art. 17(3) requires the approving authority and registration number in a prominent place. Treating a Threads post as such an ad is our reading; the cautious approach is to follow these articles: full registered name, authority and registration number, teachers' real names, and no unsupported results.
Must recruitment posts give teachers' real names?
Yes, when a post mentions the owner or staff. Art. 9(3) requires that when a cram school's recruitment or ads mention the owner or staff, their real names be disclosed and nothing be false, including when the owner or staff advertise themselves; Art. 9(13) sets a fine of NT$50,000 to NT$250,000 on the person in charge. The article does not ban stage names, so using a stage name together with the real name is our reading.
Do home tutors and online courses have to follow cram school rules?
Not necessarily directly, but they are not unregulated. Art. 2 of the regulations defines a cram school as an institution with a fixed site that recruits five or more students and charges fees; one-to-one home tutoring or purely online courses with no fixed site often fall outside it. That is our reading, and the authority decides case by case. Two things still apply: recruiting under a cram school name, or a name like one, without registration can bring a stop order and fines under Art. 24 of the Act; and Fair Trade Act Art. 21 bars enterprises from false or misleading representations and also applies to services; whether a home tutor or individual course seller counts as an "enterprise" under that article is our reading.
Is it illegal for a cram school in Taiwan to post results lists or student grades on Threads, or to write "guaranteed admission" (保證上榜)?
Posting a results list is not banned in itself, but three lines apply: the list must be true, written consent from the student or their legal representative should be obtained before publishing, and "guaranteed admission" must not be unsupported or differ from the contract. The Fair Trade Commission's cram school Q&A says a published list 必須真實、詳盡 (must be true and detailed), that obtaining written consent first is advisable (宜) and not a mandatory rule, and that without it the cram school bears the burden of proof; a clause pre-printed in the parent handbook should not stand in for a separate signed form. Names, schools and grades are personal data, and using them to recruit goes beyond the purpose they were collected for, where consent is one of the exceptions in Art. 20 of the Personal Data Protection Act (our reading). Wording such as 保證上榜 or 保證考上 should be checked against Art. 17(2) of the short-term cram school regulations, which bars exaggerated or misleading advertising, and guarantee classes must state the guarantee and its period in the contract. Ratios, multiples or claims of outscoring all other cram schools combined have been penalised by the commission (see Art. 21 of the Fair Trade Act above). Art. 69 of the Child and Youth Welfare Act covers four specific groups of children, not ordinary student photos. Whether a given post breaks the law is decided case by case by the authorities; see the consent checklist on this page for what the form can cover.
Can a recruitment post say "no refunds once paid"?
We advise against it. Art. 24 of the regulations sets refund levels: 90% before the actual start date (any part of the 10% kept that exceeds NT$1,000 must still be refunded), half before one third of the term or course hours, and nothing required after one third; registration fees, deposits and other charges may not be deducted from the total, and local rules more favourable to consumers prevail. "No refunds" does not match these rules, and we read it as misleading publicity under Art. 17(2) (our reading).
Will MindThread block this wording for cram schools and tutors today?
It blocks the wording that official texts list. As of 19 November 2026, for an account with the cram school pack on, ad wording such as 終身免費 or 永久會員 and a registered cram school's recruitment post without its registered name, approving authority and approval number go back to drafts before publishing; admission guarantees such as 保證錄取 and 保證考上, guaranteed improvement, "sure to pass" wording, results lists, pass rates, teacher titles, guarantee classes and no-refund wording are published with a warning; and any match stops a comment from being sent. The pack is off by default and you turn it on in account settings; accounts without it are not checked.
Does turning on the cram school pack make my posts legally compliant?
No. The pack matches fixed wording and does not judge meaning, so near-synonyms can slip through: "跟著我們讀,第一志願不是夢。" (study with us and your first choice is within reach) and "上過的學生都進步了。" (every student who took the class improved) both get 0 blocks and 0 warnings. It cannot check whether a teacher's name is real, whether a results list has written consent or what the contract guarantees, and it cannot see images; local cram school rules set by each city and county may be stricter, so follow your local education bureau. Its results are not legal advice, and members remain responsible for their posts and comments.

Which plan suits cram school and tutoring accounts?

As of 19 November 2026, MindThread industry packs, including the cram school pack, can be turned on with any paid plan, starting with Connect at NT$990 a month, and during the 14-day trial for new sign-ups; the Free plan shows the settings card but cannot turn a pack on. Plans differ in account limits, AI generation, auto-replies and daily patrol points.

  • Plans and prices as listed on the pricing page (price data as of 2026-11-10): Free NT$0, Connect NT$990 a month, Pro NT$1,990 a month, Business NT$5,990 a month. Account limits are 1 on Free, 3 on Connect, up to 10 on Pro and up to 50 on Business.
  • Daily patrol points are a patrol allowance included in the plan, not an extra charge, and reset every day: 300 on Connect, 500 on Pro and 1,500 on Business; the Free plan has 50 a day only during the 14-day trial after sign-up and none afterwards.
  • Every sign-up gets a 14-day Connect-level trial with no credit card and no charge at the end; patrol gets 50 points a day during the trial.
  • The Free plan links 1 Threads account, with 3 posts and 3 AI generations a day; patrol is available only during the trial.
  • A cram school's official account and teachers' personal accounts can be linked separately, each with its own persona and approve-before-send setting; Connect links up to 3 Threads accounts and Pro up to 10.
  • The dashboard has an English interface: choose the interface language in your settings, and the emails we send follow it. Each account also has a content language setting; set it to English and the AI writes that account's drafts, auto-replies and cloud patrol comments in English.

MindThread plans and pricing

Further reading

Sources and fetch dates

The rule text on this MindThread page (Threads for cram schools) was fetched from these official pages between 2026-11-05 and 2026-11-19.

This page sets out the original wording of the rules and what MindThread does today; it is not legal advice. If anything is wrong, email contact@ultralab.tw and we will check, correct it and update the data date.

Start free